Friday, August 4, 2017

Stand alone books versus series (Forum Friday #11)

Eat the whole cake at once, or be fed one slice at a time over a long period?

That's the metaphor my mind goes to when I ask the question stand-alones or series. I absolutely love both, but I decided to compile a list of my pros and cons, but obviously these won't apply to all books and some are genre specific. At lot of this is personal opinion, so you may find you disagree with my points.

Stand-alones
PROS
-Shorter read
-Less material, so generally edited better
-Only one idea but more developed
-Solid ending
-Less/no character deaths
-You don't have to wait for part two of the story
-You can only love or hate it, you can't get influenced by a horrible sequel

CONS
-It's over too soon
-Shorter storyline
-Not as many main characters
-Less drama
-Things that happen must be constrained to the time frame

Series
PROS
-The characters have more opportunity to be developed
-More things occur in the longer storyline
-Many plot twists
-New characters are introduced in later books
-Opportunity for extensive world-building
-You only have to learn about the world and characters once which sets you up for multiple reads

CONS
-Takes longer to read
-Story can get repetitive
-Main characters can become unlikeable
-The transition between books can be done badly
-Each book takes ages to release so you have to wait a long time for the next bit of the story
-The series can start off good but slowly get worse

I read series more often, but recently I've found some really good standalones. Goodreads seems to give me series suggestions the most which is the other reason I read series a lot. I love both book types, but if asked to choose Id go with series because that's how I grew up.

What about you? Which do you prefer reading and why?



No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to leave a comment, I really appreciate it, and I will respond asap. I value all comments, constructive criticism included.