Hi everyone! How are you guys? I've missed posting discussions here, and since I'm settling into the rhythm of school quite well you can expect more posts soon, I hope.
I recently read an article on time which prompted this post. Matt de la Peña writes about including darker themes in children's books, and about his illustrated book Love which publishers initially refused to publish because it was "too dark". You can read the article here.
While I've only read one of Matt de la Peña's books, book eight of the Infinity Ring series, and a short story he wrote, I absolutely agree with his points. Why should children's books filter out the darkness of "the real world?"
I definitely think this shouldn't happen at all. If children grow up believing they live in a utopia, what good will it do? It would likely harm them in the future rather than help them. If mature themes are gradually introduced into children's books, they'll get a real education and grow up informed and well equipped to deal with tough situations.
I'm a realist, and I don't think the harsh truths of our world should be "hidden" from young children, which is why I have a strong dislike of Disney childrens' movies (a topic for another time).
Do you think mature themes should be featured in children's novels? Why/why not?
I definitely am for children's books being realistic! Maybe not brutally so?! I mean we get such a small amount of time to be "innocent", per se, so it's nice when little kids can have a bit of safety like that! However I think it's a disservice to anyone to "lie" about what life is like because then it's a culture shock when you get older. It's better to introduce kids to more mature concepts while they can talk it over with parents/teachers and have support!
ReplyDeleteI'm 100% with you! It doesn't have to be brutally honest, but the truth should be told. I think even if young children have to have a cry with their parents as they talk about the issues of our world, it's good to introduce them to the bad sides of the world because they will grow up better.
Delete